Order online


9:00 AM – 12:00 PM

Online ordering NOW enabled for pick-up. Kitchen Items Only!

Please select your desserts and pastries when picking up your order.

All orders are subject to items availability. 

 My Sister’s Fault is a Puerto Rican inspired bakery located in Milford, DE.

Sweet sister Rous (baker) and savory sister Angie (cook) are always competing against each other, and dare the customers to blame one of them for your new addiction in town. We pride ourselves on serving our customers delicious Empanadas, Breakfast, Sandwiches and a variety of Pastries. 

All of our sandwiches are served in our made from scratch Sobao and Mayorca Bread! Never heard of this bread? What are you waiting to come and check us out?

Google Maps

Map Satellite